Penelope Moore
Penelope A. Moore
Shelter Island Real Estate
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Contact Me

About Me

Specializing in Shelter Island Real Estate, The Hamptons' Destination Island 

Visit Penelope's Shelter Island Real Estate Market Report, 

Over the last 17 years, Penelope has been the driving force and leader in the Shelter Island real estate market, and is the go-to real estate broker for discerning buyers and sellers. 

She has experienced record-breaking sales in multiple categories over successive years, and her success has been distinguished not just by benchmark sales, but by volume in all categories. 

Penelope understands the unique qualities inherent in the Shelter Island Market. Her knowledge is based on experience, not hearsay or the compilation of market transfers. 

Penelope has the vision to identify and track trends. Intuition and instinct, imperative in today's delicate times, served her well to spot and then capitalize on trends for her clientele during prior market downturns following the dot-com boom and events of 9/11. 

Embracing the hills and valleys of difficult real estate markets, Penelope forges on with ingenuity and dedication to her clientele and profession. 

"I am a proud Shelter Island homeowner. My efforts have resulted in a long list of satisfied clientele. Whether you are looking to purchase a starter home, a unique waterfront or want to list your property for sale, I am here to help." 

Certifications and Recognitions 

  • Approximately $390-million sold on Shelter Island
  • President's Silver Council 2013
  • President's Multi-Million Dollar Club
  • Top 5% of Corcoran Agents Company-wide
  • Top 1000 out of 59,000 NRT Associates
  • Certified EcoBroker
  • Hampton's "Power Broker" - Hampton Style
  • Consistently Ranked Top Producer 2002-Present
  • Top Ten Brokers Companywide
  • Rookie of the Year
  • Certified B.E.S.T.T. - Ellen Boyle - The Real Coach
  • National Association of Realtors
  • Hamptons and North Fork Realtors Association
  • Council of Residential Specialists
  • Womens' Council of Realtors
  • Asian Real Estate Association of America


I specialize in helping my customers find a home that suits their lifestyle and budget, and in marketing clients' residences to find a suitable buyer. My experience in real estate, contracts, and negotiation helps both parties find what they are looking for. 


I fell in love with Shelter Island on my first visit in 1995 as I disembarked the North Ferry. On that day, I toured six properties found the place I now call home on Shelter Island. I had been working in real estate in Manhattan since 1989, and delved into the Shelter Island real estate market as an associate broker in early 1997, before the island had been "discovered". 

After the tragedy of 9/11, I felt Shelter Island beckoned me to serenity and safety, so I left my full time work in commercial real estate in New York City for the quieter life on a far away island where stress is virtually unheard of. 

My life on "the rock" is placid and life-affirming in the truest sense--There is nature literally all around, the community is friendly and warm, and I have a sense of belonging. Only 125 miles from the big city, and yet a world away. I try to share my experience to others who might live in a frenetic world and are seeking a quieter, more spiritual life. 

Our office is located at 9 Grand Avenue on Shelter Island, directly across from the Shelter Island Heights Post Office 

Penelope A. Moore
Shelter Island Real Estate

PO Box 1034
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Mobile: 917-208-5519
Office: 631-749-5801
Fax: 631-204-6947 
Contact Me

A Standard of Excellence Your First Choice in Shelter Island Real Estate


We had been looking for over 2 years, in part because there was not a lot on the market and in part because we had very specific requirements. Penelope was the first broker I ever met who actually listened to what those requirements were and acted on them. After several intensive days searching she understood what we needed. For the following few months we heard from her on a regular basis but there was nothing worth making a special journey out from the city for. Then finally she found a house that you could tell was important to see asap and this was the house we bought. Having found it and agreed on the price, I was keen to close asap to make sure I didn’t have to spend another 2 years looking and Penelope worked round the clock to get things done. We’ve now lived here for two years and regularly keep in touch with Penny socially. She is definitely more than your regular real estate broker... 
A.C. New York, NY
View All

Connect With Me


Subscribe to my newsletter...

* fields are required

house realtor mls

Real Estate Websites by iHOUSEweb iconiHOUSEweb | Admin Menu