Penelope Moore
Penelope A. Moore
Shelter Island Real Estate
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Contact Me

Back to Home Page

74 North Cartwright Road - Main
Shelter Island, CA 11964

4 beds, | Residential
2,500 sq ft
Property Photo


TURN OF THE CENTURY SHELTER ISLAND WATERFRONT Located on the harbor, this classic turn-of-the-century Farmhouse was recently restored to its former grandeur with updated kitchen and baths. With sweeping lawns and established trees, the setting is both dramatic and tranquil. A two-story veranda offers elevated views of the water from comfortable summer furniture. Enter through a double door entry to an inviting living room with water views on three sides, brick fireplace, modern furnishings and the warmth of vintage beadboard. An office is just off the living room. The kitchen, which has all new cabinets and granite counters with breakfast bar, has a lovely rose garden with picket fence just outside. A TV room, full bath with frameless glass shower and sleeping loft with two twin beds is on the west side of the house. The second floor has three guest bedrooms, two of which have doors to the veranda, and a full bath with tub and shower. A pool, which is shared by the guest house, is set away from the house. Truly enchanting and a step back in time with all modern conveniences, including central air. Two week rental minimum. Ext. Season (09/01/18 - 09/30/18) $18,000; S Term (09/03/18 - 09/30/18) $9,000


  • Basement: Partial
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Heating/Cooling: Central
  • Levels: 2
  • List Date: 01/10/2014
  • Lot Size: 2.90
  • MLS #: 90269
  • Pool: In ground/Gunite
  • School District: Shelter Island
  • Type: Single Family
  • Year Built: 1900
  • View: Harborfront
Penelope A. Moore
Shelter Island Real Estate

PO Box 1034
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Mobile: 917-208-5519
Office: 631-749-5801
Fax: 631-204-6947 
Contact Me

A Standard of Excellence Your First Choice in Shelter Island Real Estate


We had been looking for over 2 years, in part because there was not a lot on the market and in part because we had very specific requirements. Penelope was the first broker I ever met who actually listened to what those requirements were and acted on them. After several intensive days searching she understood what we needed. For the following few months we heard from her on a regular basis but there was nothing worth making a special journey out from the city for. Then finally she found a house that you could tell was important to see asap and this was the house we bought. Having found it and agreed on the price, I was keen to close asap to make sure I didn’t have to spend another 2 years looking and Penelope worked round the clock to get things done. We’ve now lived here for two years and regularly keep in touch with Penny socially. She is definitely more than your regular real estate broker... 
A.C. New York, NY
View All

Connect With Me


Subscribe to my newsletter...

* fields are required

house realtor mls

Real Estate Websites by iHOUSEweb iconiHOUSEweb | Admin Menu