Penelope Moore
Penelope A. Moore
Shelter Island Real Estate
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Contact Me

Back to Home Page
$2,149,000 Just Reduced

58 Tuthill Drive + 43-64 Myrtle Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964

4 beds, | Residential
2,020 sq ft - MLS# 10418975
Property Photo


SHELTER ISLAND HARBORFRONT CAPE WITH GUEST HOUSE Located on desirable Ram Island along a private road facing Mashomack Preserve, this iconic 1934 cape is being offered as a package with three additional lots, one with guest cottage and garage and two vacant lots each approximately .27+/- acres. From a gentle elevation with stone patio and steps leading to the shoreline with fieldstone bulkhead and floating dock, the perspective from this well cared for 1,222+/- sq. ft. cottage is serene and reminiscent of another era. A four season sunroom with sitting room, dining area and windows on three sides has an open view to the harbor. The living room has a fireplace and original wood walls with an adjacent pass-through kitchen renovated in 2008 with updated appliances and country cabinets. Two guest bedrooms are off the living room, each with original built-in nautical style bureaus, as well as an updated powder room. The second floor has a dedicated master suite with water views and renovated full bath. Other recent updates include split system air conditioning and Thermopane windows. Across the road is a 798+/- sq. ft. bungalow on .2 acre with partial water views, living room, bedroom with two built-in beds, full bath and kitchenette over a two-car garage. The adjacent vacant acreage could be developed with pool. Waterfront properties with these characteristics rarely come to the market along this lane, this is a unique opportunity!


  • Basement: Full
  • Dock: Yes
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Garage: Detached, 2 spaces
  • Heating/Cooling: OHA Heat, Wall/Window Units
  • Levels: 1.5
  • List Date: 07/25/2017
  • Lot Size: .93
  • School District: Shelter Island
  • Type: Single Family
  • Year Built: 1934
  • View: Harborfront
Penelope A. Moore
Shelter Island Real Estate

PO Box 1034
Shelter Island Heights, NY
Mobile: 917-208-5519
Office: 631-749-5801
Fax: 631-204-6947 
Contact Me

A Standard of Excellence Your First Choice in Shelter Island Real Estate


We had been looking for over 2 years, in part because there was not a lot on the market and in part because we had very specific requirements. Penelope was the first broker I ever met who actually listened to what those requirements were and acted on them. After several intensive days searching she understood what we needed. For the following few months we heard from her on a regular basis but there was nothing worth making a special journey out from the city for. Then finally she found a house that you could tell was important to see asap and this was the house we bought. Having found it and agreed on the price, I was keen to close asap to make sure I didn’t have to spend another 2 years looking and Penelope worked round the clock to get things done. We’ve now lived here for two years and regularly keep in touch with Penny socially. She is definitely more than your regular real estate broker... 
A.C. New York, NY
View All

Connect With Me


Subscribe to my newsletter...

* fields are required

house realtor mls

Real Estate Websites by iHOUSEweb iconiHOUSEweb | Admin Menu